|
||||||
Reviews for Seagate Barracuda ST3750640AS 750 GB Internal Hard DriveSATA/300 - 7200 rpm - 16 MB Buffer - 3.5" - MPN: ST3750640AS
By member:
teflonron
- Jul 19, 2006
Barracuda 7200.10 750GB SATA Hard DriveStrengths: Capacity Speed Weakness: None Overall speed versus capacity is excellent. Very quiet. Some heat but no more than usual with Seagates. I'm running 16 of these in a home media server in RAID 5. Serves up three rooms with HD video with no problem. Other review mentions heat/noise issues. No problems here. Some variations from drive to drive with noise but nothing out of the ordinary. Housed in a Chenbro with ThermalTakes and thermistors on every other drive controller chip. Holds 30-35C, never above 2500 RPM. Vertical storage keeps speed unlike other high capacity drives. Power consumption is within Seagates specs. 77% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful? Top
Reply by member: dcka
Jan 6, 2007 How are you outputting The video to these screens? Do you have three video cards or is this raid a NAS that gets networked to a decoder of some sort on the other end?
By member:
Zephrant
- Aug 19, 2006
Failed after one monthStrengths: Worked great, for a month. Weakness: Failed quicky, under low use. About one month of use in a well ventilated (three fans) MythTV box that I was setting up, not even in active use for recording yet . 72% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful? Top
By member:
shaposhn
- Jun 6, 2006
consumes too much powerStrengths: slightly faster than competition Weakness: High power consumption, heat, noise. I got burns on my hands after touching this thing which was running in idle mode 99% of the time in an Adaptec ASC-300 aluminum enclosure. The idle power consumption by specs is significantly higher than other drives. I regret that I overlooked this aspect of this drive. I would suggest running this drive using an active cooler with fans, which is not an option for me because of the noise. The drive is also noisier than I expected - you can hear vibration and spinning on idle and hard clicking noises when it reads/writes. Because of the heat problem, I doubt this disk will last more than a few months, so I intend to use it mostly for various junk data and backups. If you want to store important data, I would suggest buying 2 disks, run them in a mirror RAID and use an active cooler with fans - this would create a little jet plane noise in your room, but this would dissipate the idle 20-25 watts and make the reliability acceptable. 67% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful? Top
Reply by member: tmhcorp
Jul 12, 2006 After reading this comment I checked Seagate's website. They list all their Barracuda 7200 drives with the same power consumption regardless of capacity. It is:
Reply by member: JimEagleOne
Jul 13, 2006 It's hard for me to believe that shaposhn thought he could get away with putting the world's highest capacity drive inside an unventilated enclosure, and then not expect to fry eggs on it. I've got that exact model Adaptec enclosure and wouldn't risk putting that drive in it. But downgrading Seagate's product for his own oversight is punishing Seagate for their great success. He's got it backwards. This drive is a Jaguar among hard drives and I wouldn't put it in a cage. I even use active ventilation on mere 20GB, 7200 rpm drives. What was he thinking?
Reply by member: cur1osul
Jul 13, 2006 JimEagleOne is right I use fans on all my drives except a maxtor 40Gb that anyway stays very close to some other drive's fan.
Reply by member: spinslow
Aug 8, 2009 Thankfully thmcorp here posted the power specs.
By member:
JustPlainDon
- Oct 1, 2006
Speed demon hard drives!Strengths: Capacity & speed Weakness: Price/GB is higher than smaller drives. Just built a new system with lots of horsepower for handling video applications and 3D software in a Windows Vista 64-bit environment. I have 2 of these 750 GB drives in this system. The hard drives can provide sustained read/write speeds of 75/69 MB/sec using Storm test (Canopus.com). This easily surpasses anything I would currently need for capturing digital video. The sweet part is moving or copying huge video files between and within drives. These drives are speed demons. So far they have not appeared to run hot as one other reviewer mentioned. 67% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful? Top
By anonymous - Sep 27, 2006
Warm, but fast and quietStrengths: 750GB in a single internal drive. Weakness: Warm. This drive does run relatively hot, but no more so than a typical 10,000 RPM Sata. It's a 750GB Drive - cooling should be a consideration before buying such an expensive and dense HD. Grab a coolmax aluminum enclosure, they're about $25 and will significantly reduce the drive temperature. 67% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful? Top
By member:
Ultimate_Entertainment
- Feb 1, 2007
Simply The Best!Strengths: SATA connection, with up to 3Mpbs data transfer rates; very generous 5-Year Warranty; A massive 16MB of Cache --the most available -- for great stability; big 750GB storage capacity running 7200RPM. Weakness: Might be a bit tricky when seting up the RAID with other SATA Hard Disks, but not too difficult you carefully read the instructions before setup. Other than that, no other probelms found. One might ask, "What would you need a hard drive with 750GB of storage for?" Well I remember when someone asked me that similar question about 10 or 12 years ago, except that it was for a 4GB hard drive instead, and that was a pretty large size at it's time, but that was when the Internet was starting to emerge in the common household to mostly send & receive E-mails for dial-up WWW, and typing Word or Excel documents. But since then, we've had things like Broadband Internet Speeds, WI-FI, Bluetooth, VIOP, DVDs, music downloads, Live WebChats, and so on -- & when adding all that stuff up over time, that can take a lot of storage space on your hard drive, plus when you think abvout adding newer, upcomming technologies, like Windows Vista, Blue-Ray, HD-DVD, Bluetooth 2.0, 802.11N Wi-Fi, videophones, & High Definition -- suddenly 750GB won't seem like enough. As for this particular brand model, it's much faster & easier to setup compared to the old ATA (PATA) type, SEAGATE offers a 5-year warranty, compared to 1-, 2-, or 3-year ones from some other brands, and I've yet to experience any probelms and/or errors with any of them. It also offers the maximum amount of cache, 16MB, for better stability, compared to most others that might only offer 8MB. 50% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful? Top
By member:
markblas
- Nov 18, 2006
Great Hard driveStrengths: large volume Weakness: none yet - other than price Bought for home theater PC (htpc). Large volume is excellant for storing DIVX movies and MP3's. Have not noticed drive too hot as per (few) other reviews. Very fast. Very quiet. 33% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful? Top
By member:
bballcards
- Apr 20, 2007
Plenty of Space....Noise Issues DisappointingStrengths: High capacity hard drive, fast operation. Weakness: Pretty loud when compared to other hard drives I have. I bought this hard drive to upgrade the hard drive in my TiVo Series 3. It certainly works, providing 3x the capacity of the standard TiVo Series 3 hard drive, but it's LOUD. This makes a big difference when you're watching TV, as that incessant hard drive noise can detract from the TV experience (unless you turn up the volume really high). I was disappointed with the noise. If you're using it in a PC/server, I don't think it'll bother you too much. But in the environment I'm using it in, the noise is disappointing. 0% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful? Top
By member:
damnwombat
- Aug 27, 2008
oem 1tb barracudaStrengths: huge capacity huge cache short non-sequential seek times operating temperature Weakness: needs underlighting and a lift kit to go with the rims and spoiler Great drive. It follows the SATA II standard so it works with new computers well, but you can jumper it so you can use it with SATA ports. Fast, reliable, and works great in an array. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful? Top
By member:
tkps
- Sep 7, 2007
Barracuda 7200.10 750GB Hard Drive (Serial ATA-300,...Strengths: Provides your with enough storage space for all your digital needs. Weakness: Little noisy. This was a great buy from a seller I can trust and depend on. They are one of the best seller out there whom you can buy without any worries. Please keep up your great job. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful? Top
By member:
zipmale
- Jun 30, 2007
Barracuda 7200.10 750GB Hard Drive (Serial ATA-300,...Strengths: fast speed, big capasity, affordable price Weakness: no 4 pin power connector, little noise while processing data this hard-drive is one the best on today's market. if your pc case does not have enough slots for hard drives it's better to purchase this one because nowadays people have so many video files which better be stored in one place; so three of those hard-drives will give you over 2 tb of space for your movie collection. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful? Top
By member:
awint
- Jun 13, 2007
Barracuda 7200.10 750GB Hard DriveStrengths: affordable price Weakness: no regular 4 pin power connector This harddrive is pretty good. Of course it was better to buy 2x500 Gb for the price I paid for this harddrive but my PC did not have enough harddrive slots. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful? Top
By member:
tony1972
- Jun 11, 2007
Fast, Reliable, top notch driveStrengths: Fast, Reliable, good price Per/GB Weakness: none Heard comments about heat and noise, but have not experienced myself. Have 3 750's installed a Gateway MicroBTX case. They perform very well. I was very weary after some bad experiences with other mfg. I use the drives for storing my DVD Collection and watch on Media Center 2005. At about 5GB's per movie, the space gets filled very quickly. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful? Top
reviewgist.com - Dec 15, 2009
Best Hard Drive with Price Under $100 and Capacity Atleast 40 GB
Performance is Good according to 7 Hard Drive experts. -- "Great performance."-tech.co.uk -- "Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 750GB combines voluminous storage and high-end performance"-pcworld.com Read more to find expert opinions on more features like Technology, Noise, etc. Top
testseek.com - Oct 31, 2008
Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 750GB SATA300 ST3750640AS
Testseek.com has collected 35 expert reviews for Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 750GB SATA300 ST3750640AS and the average expert rating is 88 of 100. The average score reflects the expert community’s view on this product. Click below and use Testseek.com to see all ratings, product awards and conclusions. Top
PCWorld - May 17, 2006
Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 750GB
Gargantuan drive offers record-high storage capacity thanks to perpendicular recording, and has top-notch write performance. TopAdvertisement
|
Barracuda 7200.10 750GB SATA Hard Drive
Strengths: FAST. Very good maximum throughput (best measured speed at 73MB/sec)
Weakness: Price is more than 25¢/GB. None other noticed so far.
I use this drive for large (75MB-300MB) Photoshop picture files.
Being able to load, save, and move these files around quickly is very important to me, and this drive does that very well.
I have been running this drive for a week. So far it is not noticeably louder or hotter than any of the other drives (WD250, MAX300, HIT160) that I am running in my machine.
It is installed with 3 other drives in the 3.5" drive cage in my cheap case, all about 1/2" apart. They are all cooled by a cheap, quiet 4" fan and they all run warm, but not hot, to the touch.
My guess that the reviewer who is complaining about high heat and noise has an unusually bad drive (or I have an unusually good one).
If you need large capacity and high speed, this is your drive. Otherwise get a 300GB drive because they are now at the price/size/performance sweet spot.
100% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful?